One of the mantras of charter school operators is “choice.” They want to give parents a choice between their charter school and those nasty public schools. Politicians and school reformers will tell you that giving kids a choice will force bad public schools to get better (or be closed).
Another thing charter school operators highlight is their wait list to get in. They say this is proof that people want out of the pubic schools and want more charter schools. The flip side of those wait lists is that the kids on those lists didn’t have a choice to go to that charter school – just the ones who got in had a “choice.” If a family moves into a house next door to a charter school and try to send their kids there, the school can say, “no, we won’t take you – you have to go to the pubic school.” This is part of the business model of a charter school – calculate the number of kids you can accept in order to be profitable and then close the door. Of course public school’s have to enroll all the kids who reside there, regardless of how many.
Do children with special needs get the choice to attend charter schools? Or children who not speak English? Some do, but enrollment statistics for charter schools show they enroll a disproportionately small percentage of special education students and ELL (English Language Learners) students.
How about the kids who have difficulty in school – aren’t motivated, just can’t sit still, act out? Even if they get into a charter school, if the child isn’t a model student the school can boot them out. Statistics show charter schools have unusually high suspension/expulsion rates.
So when you hear people talk about “school choice” realize whose choice it is – the charter schools’ choice. Charter school operators choose how many students they will accept, what specialized services they will provide, and what type of students they will serve. Public schools don’t randomly exclude students – and we are better off because they don’t.